Manchester United are the most successful team in Community Shield history. The Red Devils have won the trophy 21 times, 17 of which were outright wins and four were shared.
In 2026, Arsenal could close the gap with a 17th outright win of the Community Shield. The Shield still matters because it opens the domestic season with a proper trophy on the line, and that gives supporters an early read on who might carry momentum into the weeks ahead.
Last Update: August 2026
Which team has won the Community Shield the most?
Manchester United sit alone at the top of the Community Shield roll of honour with 21 total wins, making them the most successful team in Community Shield history.
Their tally includes 17 outright victories and four shared titles, which keeps them clear of Arsenal on both overall success and the number of actual wins. Arsenal are next with 17 total wins, including 16 outright victories and one shared title.
That means Arsenal’s Community Shield win total is impressive, but it still leaves them four behind United overall and one behind on outright wins. Among the best Community Shield teams, those two set the pace, with Liverpool on 16 total wins and 11 outright wins in the chase behind them.
Which teams have won the Community Shield?
Throughout its storied history tracking back to 1908, the Community Shield has crowned 26 different outright or co-champions. Here’s a full list of the Community Shield winners ranked by the number of times they’ve lifted or shared the title:
- 21 Wins: Manchester United
- 17 Wins: Arsenal
- 16 Wins: Liverpool
- 9 Wins: Everton
- 7 Wins: Manchester City, Tottenham Hotspur
- 4 Wins: Chelsea, Wolverhampton Wanderers
- 2 Wins: Leeds United, Leicester City, West Bromwich Albion, Burnley
- 1 Win: Newcastle United, Brighton & Hove Albion, Blackburn Rovers, Huddersfield Town, Cardiff City, Sheffield Wednesday, Sunderland, Bolton Wanderers, Derby County, Nottingham Forest, Crystal Palace, Portsmouth, West Ham United, Aston Villa.
Who’re the favourites for the next Community Shield?
The early match winner odds point to a tight contest, with Arsenal priced at 6/4, Manchester City at 13/8, and the 90-minutes draw at 23/10. That says plenty about how evenly matched the game looks, even before a ball is kicked.
For anyone tracking the most successful team in Community Shield history, the bigger picture is that both clubs remain near the top of the trophy count and are used to turning these August fixtures into statements.
Arsenal have a clear route to making more history if they get the job done. Another win would strengthen their place in the list of most Community Shield wins, and it would also keep the pressure on Manchester United’s lead at the summit.
As the first true competitive showpiece event of the season, you can track the news and tips for the 2026 Community Shield here at 888.
Which team has won the Community Shield without draws?
Remove the shared titles and Manchester United still lead the way with 17 outright Community Shield wins. Arsenal follow with 16 outright wins, while Liverpool sit on 11.
That is why the outright category matters so much when fans compare the most successful team in Community Shield history with the clubs trying to catch them. It’s also why the football odds for Arsenal or City to lift the trophy in 2026 are of increased focus this time around.
If Arsenal win the 2026 Community Shield, they will tie Manchester United on 17 outright Community Shield wins. That would not change the overall lead, but it would make the race at the top feel much tighter and add another wrinkle to the debate over the best Community Shield teams.
No matter who lifts it, the Community Shield remains a neat first marker of the season. It is a trophy, a tone-setter, and a reminder that the campaign starts with something worth winning.
Safer Gambling: Gambling should be enjoyed as entertainment, not as a way to make money or solve financial problems. For help and advice, visit www.begambleaware.org. Please gamble responsibly.
